Friday, July 8, 2016

Sioux Rescue of Gareth MacNair

Worthington Whittredge, "Encampment on the Platte River," c. 1866
It was October in the Nebraska Territory and there was a chill in the air. The trees had long since started to change color. Gareth MacNair was already three months behind schedule. He was going to have to head south for the Butterfield Stage Trail to avoid getting caught on the Bozeman Trail during the winter.
Appomattox Courthouse was six months ago and Gareth was glad the war was over. When he received word of General Lee’s surrender, he stripped off his grey lieutenant’s jacket, saddled his paint and headed west in search of a little peace and quiet.
While he had fought for the Confederacy, Gareth really didn’t care about either side. Jefferson Davis was fighting to maintain slavery under the guise of “state’s rights” and Abraham Lincoln was fighting for tyranny under the guise of “preserving the union.” All Gareth wanted was to be left alone, but the Union drew him into the war. They ensured that Gareth would not only fight for the Confederacy, but hate the damn Yanks for the rest of his life.


In 1861 when the War Between the States began, Gareth MacNair was living happily and mostly peacefully on his small farm in Tennessee with his wife, Maria and two sons, Jim and John.
While many families had sent their sons off to war with foolhardy assurances that the war would be over in a matter of weeks, Gareth had forbidden his boys from enlisting. He could see right through the lies of the Secessionists and he would have no part in maintaining slavery or defending it and neither would he abide his sons being associated with that human degradation.
“What you want us to do, Pa?” Jim had asked incredulously, “You want us to fight with Lincoln’s boys?”
“I don’t want you to fight at all,” Gareth had stated flatly. “You’re gonna stay home and stay out of this. You hear?”
His boys didn’t talk to him for a month, but they obeyed him.
One day in April of 1862, his boys had gone out hunting. When they didn’t come home by sunset, Gareth and Maria began to worry. In the dying blood red light of dusk, Gareth grabbed his Kentucky long rifle, the same kind that made Jack Hinson famous during the War, and walked out the front door with every intention to search for his missing boys. As Gareth stepped through the door, he looked across the potato field and saw uniformed horsemen emerging from the trees on the other side. It was a small company of Union cavalry.
As the cavalry cleared the tree line, Gareth saw two scared and tired looking men; hands tied together and tethered to the last two horses, jogging to keep from falling. They were his sons!
Gareth set his rifle against the door and waited anxiously as the cavalry rode down the path to the front of his house. A tall, haughty officer with captain’s bars on the shoulders of his blue uniform raised his hand and signaled the company to stop. As the company came to a halt, the captain continued forward on horseback.
The captain’s voice was oily smooth, but all business with tinge of Virginia drawl. “These bushwhackers claim that this is the home of Secesh sympathizers.”
Gareth could feel a combination of fear and anger as the realization that his boys were being accused of a crime against the Union that carried the death penalty. Even worse, Gareth himself was being accused of being a Confederate sympathizer. As the blood filled his face, he did everything he could to stay calm.
“No, sir,” Gareth replied deliberately. “You are mistaken. My boys ain’t bushwhackers and we ain’t on any side here.”
“These are your sons?” the captain noted with surprise. There was a condescending air to every word the captain spoke. “If they are not bushwhackers, then perhaps you can explain why they were firing on Union troops.”
“Pa,” John cried out, fear and desperation in his voice. “We didn’t. I swear.”
“My boys went out hunting this morning,” Gareth explained calmly. “They were probably shooting at game.”
The captain smiled pure evil.
“Just the sort of explanation I would expect from Secesh.” He turned to his men and stated simply, “Kill the boys, hang their heads on the gate posts. Burn the buildings and fields.”
“NO!” Maria cried out from inside and ran through the door, down the steps and sprinted toward Jim and John.
Time slowed down. Gareth remembered every sensation. He felt the tingle of every hair on his body and every bead of sweat beginning to secrete from his upper lip and forehead. For the rest of his life, he could recall in detail every moment and motion of the next few seconds.
Four soldiers in the rear dismounted their horses. Two of them, lieutenants, drew their sabers with a ring of cold steel. The other two grabbed Jim and John and forced them to the ground.
Gareth stood frozen with mouth agape – unbelieving.
As Maria crossed the clearing between the house and the potato field, the captain pulled his Colt Dragoon revolver and fired a single shot.
Gareth flinched back to reality and watched in horror as his wife fell motionless to the ground. His eyes widened. He knew in his heart of heart, there was nothing he could do, but he was going to kill that Captain. He turned to grab his Kentucky long rifle, but it was too late. The captain had already leveled his revolver and fired again.
Gareth felt fire in his back and the wind was knocked out of him. The shot spun him around and he stumbled off the porch and fell to the ground. As the darkness closed in, his last sights were his dead wife in a pool of blood and the Union lieutenants bringing their swords down on the necks of his struggling sons.


He had been found by Confederate scouts and hospitalized for over a month in bed. He spent another two months in recovery. After his recovery and because of his combat experience in the Mexican war, he was offered a commission as a lieutenant. He gladly put on Confederate gray and took up arms in order to kill as many murderous Yanks as he could.
With the war over, his wife and sons dead, his home burned and his burned land untenable, Gareth MacNair had no home to go to.


He was in the southwest region of the Nebraska Territory. Even though he was behind schedule, it was actually a better time to be in the region. If he had made the time he hoped and arrived in the area three months earlier, he would have walked right into a war between Union Army and several local Indian tribes. The Union, with superior firepower had won and the region was at peace for now. Of course the war was a problem that the Union Army created in the first place with typical government tyranny. At any rate, the travel was safe for now while the Sioux, Cheyenne, and Arapaho licked their wounds and plotted in their camps.
Gareth was riding cross country, due south, cutting his own trail. His only possessions besides the clothes on his body and the wide brimmed felt hat on his head were his Army pack, his old trusty Kentucky long rifle, a Henry repeating rifle he took from a dead Yankee during the War, two 1851 Colt Navy revolvers he’d had since the Mexican War, a Bowie knife on his belt, and his sturdy paint horse.
His travels took him through some beautiful hill country. It was an easy ride and very peaceful. It was just the thing that Gareth needed. Gareth could easily see why people wanted to settle in these parts. He was tempted to stop and stake a claim himself.
The peace of the day was cut by gunshots. Gareth’s head snapped to the front and the paint flinched, startled. It sounded like only one or two guns firing, but they were firing repeatedly. There was definitely something bad going down and Gareth wanted no part of it.
Over the sounds of gunshots, Gareth could also hear screaming—lots of it. That was enough to pique his curiosity. It sounded like a slaughter.
The gunshots seemed to come from the south, just ahead of him. In the hills, it was sometimes hard to tell.
As Gareth spurred his paint up the hill, the gunshots ceased, but there was still the sound of screaming. There was only one scream. The rest had fallen silent, but that one scream was filled with the utmost terror.
Just before he crested the hill, Gareth reigned in his horse and jumped off. He quickly tied his horse to a tree just below the crest of the hill and pulled down both of his rifles. His Henry rifle was good at close range and had saved his bacon on several occasions. He figured he would need his long rifle, though. He could shoot a squirrel out of a tree from two hundred yards with a good shooting support and he had used it to send many Yankees to meet the devil.
His Henry stayed loaded, but he had to load his long rifle and did so as he climbed the hill. At the top of the hill were a cluster of boulders. He walked behind them, set his Henry rifle against the rocks and brought his long rifle to the ready. He slowly peered around the west side of the rocks looking down the hill. Immediately, his blood began to boil.
The view from the top of the hill revealed a river running west to east. This was the South Platte River and Gareth had expected to cross it today. The river was lined with beautiful fall colored cottonwood trees. The leaves blazed fiery red, orange, and yellow, and smoldering browns.
The beauty ended there. Along the bank, there were at least a dozen lifeless Indian bodies – men, women, and children dead from gunshot wounds. To the east of the bodies, there were two horses tied to trees.
And two U.S. Army soldiers in those goddamn Yankee blue jackets. One wore sergeant stripes and the other was a private. They were wrestling with a struggling Indian girl.
Gareth’s mind was thrust back in time three and half years. Maria running, falling dead, the burning pain in his back, his sons dying at the hands of Union soldiers. The evil glare of the Union captain.
“Git ‘er hands,” the sergeant directed.
The private grabbed her left, but with her free hand, she delivered a solid right hook that sent the private reeling forcing him to let her go. She was strong.
She tried to make a run for it, but the sergeant was faster. In three steps he grabbed her leather tunic and backhanded her, knocking her to the ground. She was dazed, but still conscious. She tried to get up, but her head was spinning and could only crawl.
“Damn it!” the sergeant exclaimed with a sneer, “She won’t be as much fun like this.” He turned to the private, “Go on boy fetch some rope.”
“Alright!”
As the private ran back to the horses to retrieve the rope, the sergeant walked slowly to the Indian girl. This was Gareth’s chance. If he was going to rescue this girl, from these vile monsters he was going to have to take advantage of the lull. Gareth leaned against the rock for support.
The sergeant bent down and grabbed the Indian girl by her hair and spun her over. He straddled her, sitting on her pelvis. She tried to resist, but the sergeant was easily able to grab her hands and hold them over her head.
Gareth lined up the sergeant’s head in his sights. It was a long shot, but Gareth had more than two decades of experience and elevation on his side.
The private was already at the sergeant’s side with the rope and he began quickly tying the Indian girl’s hands.
“Whoo hoo!” the private yelled excitedly, “I ain’t had me none in months.”
“Just git ‘er tied,” the sergeant instructed, “We got plenty of time.”
Gareth placed the pad of his index finger on the trigger and took a deep breath. He could feel his heart beat slowing. Calm. Halfway through his exhale, he squeezed.
Just as the private finished tying the girl’s hands, they were both sprayed by something wet. He looked down to see the girl’s tunic and face spattered with blood.
Before he could react, he was startled by the report of rifle fire. At the same time, the sergeant’s lifeless and nearly decapitated body slumped to the ground.
The private forgot about the Indian girl, sprang to his feet, pulled his Colt Army revolver, and sprinted for the nearest tree.
From the top of the hill, Gareth was almost done reloading by the time the private got to the tree. The private would have good cover behind the tree, but he wouldn’t be able to stay there forever and Gareth was patient.
The private didn’t know where the shooter was, but he knew the report had come from the north. He assumed the shooter was in the cluster of rocks at the top of the hill. Probably a damned Sioux brave he and the sergeant had missed while following this group. He had good cover, but if the shooter came down the hill, he would be vulnerable. He and the sergeant had gone AWOL from Fort Laramie two weeks prior, so there was no help coming for them. If he could make it to his horse, he might have a shot at making it out alive.
Gareth watched the tree intently. The muscles in his arms were on fire, holding the rifle steady. The Kentucky long rifle was only ten pounds and the support of the rock helped ease some of the weight. Nevertheless, holding that position was starting to take its toll.
Suddenly, the private dashed for his horse. He fired to the north indiscriminately, hoping to cover his run, but Gareth was way out of the revolver’s range.
He followed the soldier’s run, leading him by a few yards trying to take the soldier’s speed into account. He squeezed the trigger once more and the trusty old rifle roared in response.
Gareth wasn’t sure he hit the soldier at first. He was still running. After a few steps, the soldier stumbled and fell lifeless in a pool of his own blood.
Gareth slung his long rifle, grabbed his Henry rifle and started quickly down the hill. The girl was still tied and was trying to crawl away from the gore.
At a brisk jog, Gareth made it to the bottom of the hill in just under two minutes. The girl had crawled slowly about twenty yards. She was still dazed from being hit by the sergeant and sobbing uncontrollably.
Gareth rushed to the girl’s side. He put his hand on her shoulder and she spun on her back wide eyed.
“Omakiya ye!” She screamed, shrilly, “Ayustan ye!”
“Sh, sh,” he tried to console her, “It’s ok.”
She continued struggling. She didn’t understand that Gareth was trying to help. This was Sioux territory which meant she was probably speaking Lakota. Gareth had a lot of experience with Indians and their languages. Growing up in the east he had learned some Cherokee and during the Mexican war he learned a lot of Apache, but in Lakota, he could only remember one word and he hoped it was the right one.
“Okopesnian,” Gareth said calmly, “Safe. You understand?”
The girl collapsed on her back, weeping, but relaxed. She understood him. Gareth meant her no harm.
He set his rifles down. The girl was still upset and anything could be seen as a threat and he didn’t want to startle her into a fit again. He pointed to his Bowie knife and then to her hands which were still tied together. He then made a sawing motion with his hand against the rope. She nodded in understanding.
Gareth pulled the knife from its sheath and cut her bonds. He fully expected her to make a run for it. He wouldn’t have blamed her and he would have let her go. Instead, she flung herself into his arms and held him in a tight, fearful, sobbing embrace.
“Pilamayaye,” she sobbed quietly. Gareth assumed that was some sort of expression of gratitude.
He held her for a moment longer, stroking the back of her head. He was aware of her softness pressing against him. He hadn’t held a woman close for three and a half years. This girl was young – younger than him anyway. In spite of the austere life of the Sioux, the luster of youth had not yet left her. In spite of her comparative youth, she was certainly more woman than girl. He felt the pangs of desire that had become almost unfamiliar to him.
Gareth put those thoughts aside and pulled the girl away from him by the shoulders. He looked into her eyes. They were deep brown, almost black, almond shaped, and tender. Again, the pang of desire coursed through him.
“Come on,” he said, looking away uncomfortably, “Let’s get you cleaned up.”
Standing, Gareth helped the Indian girl to her feet. He took her hand gently and motioned toward the river.
“Clean,” Gareth said.
The girl nodded, but stood still. She raised her hand and pointed to herself.
“Mapiya.”
“Mapeeya,” Gareth repeated, “That’s your name? Mapeeya?”
The girl nodded and said, “Huh. Mapiya emaciyapi.” She pointed at Gareth inquiringly.
He nodded, pointed at her and repeated again, “Mapiya” he caught the pronunciation better this time, then he pointed to himself and said, “Gareth.”
“Gahr-eeth,” she tried. Mapiya’s mouth was still quivering from crying, but she forced a smile and walked to the river’s edge.
Gareth walked behind Mapiya and she began to lift her tunic over her head. He stopped short looking at the bare tawny skin of her back. She was undressing and with no shame. As much as the man in Gareth wanted to keep watching, the gentleman in him turned around.
He didn’t think she would understand, but with is back to her, Gareth pointed up the hill and said, “I have to go get my horse.”
“Huh,” he heard her reply. It wasn’t a question and Gareth had heard Mapiya say it before. He hoped that meant “yes” and that she understood. He went to the horses, untied one, mounted and rode to fetch his paint.


Gareth took inventory of the soldiers’ gear. They had a Springfield 1863 rifle and a Pattern 1853 Enfield rifle. He had no use for either of those weapons. Each of the soldiers had a Colt Army revolver. Since Gareth already had his own revolvers, he thought about giving them to Mapiya – maybe one of the rifles too. She would probably leave. Even though she was in Sioux country, she was alone and she would need protection.
Besides weapons and ammunition, they had simple packs and rations, and the inventory went quickly. He turned to look at the dead Indians scattered about. He wanted to honor the dead, but he wasn’t sure of Sioux traditions. Some Indians practiced sky burial and some burned their dead. He didn’t have time for either and besides, both of those practices would probably create more problems than they would solve.
One of the dead soldiers had a spade. Gareth decided to risk offending Mapiya and began digging graves in some brush away from the river. He hoped the plants would hide the graves.
Hours passed. Gareth was aware that Mapiya was taking inventory of her own people’s possessions. She found clean clothes and tied drag sleds to one of the Army horses and also to Gareth’s paint on which she began stacking various items she found: furs, packs, food, and other items. Evidently she planned on staying with him for a while. They both did their work quietly.
When the graves were finished, Gareth began to drag the body of one of the Sioux – an old man – toward the first grave. Mapiya appeared and grabbed the old man’s feet. She wasn’t crying anymore, but she was very serious and they both gently lowered the body into the first grave.
Within minutes all the Sioux bodies had been laid to rest. Gareth picked up the shovel. Mapiya grabbed his hand and shook her head. Gareth had the feeling she was going to say some kind of words over the graves, so he removed his sweat soaked, wide brimmed, felt hat and placed it over his heart.
Mapiya began singing and dancing haltingly around the graves. The tune was hauntingly beautiful and filled the air with a kind of magic that touched Gareth’s soul. Gareth couldn’t understand the words, but he could understand the emotion. By the looks of the people now lying in graves, Mapiya had lost her family today.


They made camp on a higher plateau above the river. After bathing himself, Gareth shot two rabbits and Mapiya was cooking them over a fire on an improvised spit. As Mapiya cooked, Gareth made a makeshift tent for Mapiya by tying a rope between two trees, throwing some Army blankets over the top and staking down the corners. He planned on sleeping in the open air, but figured a lady might like some privacy.
As they worked, Gareth couldn’t help but steal glances at Mapiya.
She had let her raven black hair down to dry and it made her look less girlish. Her hair was combed back, but still fell in luxurious, silky streams over her shoulders as she worked. Her face was soft and angled with high cheekbones, and a slight blush of youth. She had found a clean, simple deerskin dress that fell gracefully over her athletic yet feminine body.
Mapiya caught Gareth’s eye as he tried to steal another glance. He quickly looked away, embarrassed. He pretended to be absorbed with the tent. When he looked back, he could see that she was smiling.


With dinner finished, Gareth laid out his own bedroll next to a tree and sat down leaning against the tree with his Henry rifle next to him.
Mapiya cleared her throat and Gareth looked up. She was standing next to the tent holding some kind of rolled up fur.
She pointed to the tent and said, “Heyuway.”
Gareth had no idea what she said, but responded anyway. “Yeah. That’s for you.”
Mapiya pointed to Gareth, beckoned with her hand and then pointed to the tent. “Heyuway.”
Gareth understood. Mapiya wanted him to go in the tent.
“No ma’am,” Gareth replied, smiling. Patting the ground he said, “I’ll be fine out here.”
There was a look on Mapiya’s face. Was that disappointment? She disappeared into the tent.
Gareth was tempted to go into the tent, but he knew what would happen in there. Mapiya was beautiful and although he called her a girl because she was younger than him by probably fifteen to twenty years, she was all woman. Gareth had never dishonored a lady. He hadn’t even lain with his own wife until they were married.
As he began to drift off into a light sleep Gareth listened to Mapiya moving around inside the tent. He wondered how the Sioux were married. He wondered what that would be like. He wondered what marriage to Mapiya would be like.
She had awakened in him something that he hadn’t felt in three and a half years. Since the death of Maria and his sons, Gareth had only felt anger and had been consumed with hate and the desire to exact retribution on the Union. He had no room for love. He didn’t even care for his own men—they were simply tools to help him carry out his revenge.

Mapiya had put dent in his hate. For the first time since the death of his family, Gareth felt the need to protect something instead of destroy it. He felt that he could love Mapiya. He felt that he did love Mapiya. In a sense, she had rescued him just as much as he had rescued her.